Trolling

trollWhen I was a kid, my family every summer went to a Minnesota lake because my father enjoyed fishing. Every day we went trolling for bass and pike . . .

Oh. Not that kind of trolling?

INTERNET trolling is a whole other thing. Why do people do it?

Last night, someone posted a comment on this blog in response to my very brief post about the recent Robert Coover story in The New Yorker. I didn’t think much of the story, so I didn’t have much to say about it. The commenter, though, in classic troll mode, said my reading of the story was obtuse and that I was an ignoramus. Really? That’s an appropriate comment in a public forum? I could have deleted the comment, but I let it go and asked the troll to do better. (I’ve checked around the Internet, and I’m finding anyone saying anything particularly brilliant about the Coover story, but maybe Mr. Troll will have something to offer.)

Then, this morning, in a forum I participate in some times, a friend posted that he had been criticized online for his use of the past perfect tense in an Amazon.com review. What kind of a troll does that? (I looked at the usage and it looks right to me, even after referring to a couple of usage texts.) I Google this particular troll and harping on the use of the past perfect appears to be his thing. I guess everyone needs a hobby, but he should probably try bowling.

I’ve also been following an online discussion in my local newspaper. In response to a letter to the editor, one local curmudgeon made the argument that the Civil War was about “States’ Rights.” Another commenter, though, made the stronger argument that it was about slavery. The former, a familiar troll in that forum, quickly lost his cool and began with ad hominem attacks (go back where you came from, you’re ignorant, etc.) but the latter has kept his cool and stuck to the facts. (The only thing I contributed to the argument was a link to an article suggesting that 90-95% of historians–as opposed to Internet trolls–agree that the war was about slavery.)

And yesterday, an old friend of mine launched an argument on Facebook about President Obama and the Affordable Care Act. He was making spurious claims and didn’t respond well when confronted with facts. He got angry–not just at me, but at all the other people who pounced on him–and left. Deleted all his posts, “unfriended” me, and disappeared.

The Internet is a weird place.

3 thoughts on “Trolling”

  1. Interesting post. (I started following your blog for the discussions of New Yorker stories, but cancelled on New Yorker because I got fed up with their arrogant hostile practices toward customers).

    My first thought was to agree. I publish often on Seekingalpha.com and have had more-than-ample experience with trolls and wondered, if in your experience, the worst tend to be anonymous. That’s been my experience. It’s easy to be whacko when nobody knows who you are.

    Lately, though, I’ve been reconsidering. I attend several local meetup.com discussion groups and book clubs and have noticed that extreme whacky troll-like sentiments, much as you describe, are put forth even face to face. I’m wondering if the internet is getting a bad rap for things that have always been there (but manifested less instantaneously pre internet).

    1. You may be right, Marc. However, I haven’t really experienced that–maybe because I only go to public meetings that are more homogeneous. It used to be that anonymity made things worse, but now people don’t seem to care. Or maybe everyone has a pseudonym for the purpose of trolling . . .

  2. The internet is only a microcosm of the greater world. In fact, people find it easier to hide behind their coffee stained laptop keys and make a bunch of crude, shallow comments and arguments than actually take the time out to think and understand the topic they are so viciously attacking. “Troll” is just another name for bully. It would be a perfect world if we could untie our hands to freely type what is on our minds and hearts, if we could find the benefit in the anonymity the internet offers us and use it to open our minds without fear of being judged, rather than getting a rise out of harassing and belittling our fellow internet dwellers. Happy dwelling!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.